Merge Intervals vs Line Sweep
Quick Answer
Use Merge Intervals when you need to combine overlapping intervals into a non-overlapping set, insert a new interval, or find gaps. Use Line Sweep when you need to count overlapping intervals at any point, find the maximum number of overlaps, or process events that happen at specific coordinates.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Aspect | Merge Intervals | Line Sweep |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Sort by start, merge overlapping | Create start/end events, sort, sweep left to right |
| Time complexity | O(n log n) | O(n log n) |
| Space complexity | O(n) for output | O(n) for events array |
| Output | Set of non-overlapping intervals | Counts, max overlap, or derived values |
| Best for | Merging, inserting, removing intervals | Counting overlaps, scheduling, resource allocation |
| Limitations | Cannot easily count overlaps at a point | Does not produce merged intervals directly |
| Key signal | "Merge overlapping", "insert interval" | "Maximum overlap", "min rooms", "max concurrent" |
When to Use Merge Intervals
- -You need to combine overlapping intervals into a minimal non-overlapping set.
- -You need to insert a new interval into an already-sorted list and merge any resulting overlaps.
- -You need to find gaps between intervals or the union of multiple interval sets.
- -The problem asks whether two intervals overlap or to find intersections between two sorted interval lists.
When to Use Line Sweep
- -You need to find the maximum number of overlapping intervals at any point (minimum meeting rooms, maximum concurrent events).
- -The problem involves resource allocation — how many resources are needed to handle all requests simultaneously?
- -You need to process events at specific points and track a running count of active intervals.
- -The problem involves 2D geometry — skyline problem, rectangle area union, or sweep-line with a balanced BST.
Key Differences
What they produce
Merge Intervals produces a new list of intervals (the merged result). Line Sweep produces counts or values derived from processing events in order — it answers questions like "how many intervals are active at time t?"
How they handle intervals
Merge Intervals sorts intervals by start time and iterates, extending the current interval or starting a new one. Line Sweep decomposes each interval into two events (+1 at start, -1 at end), sorts all events, and scans left to right while maintaining a counter.
Extensibility
Line Sweep is more general and extensible. It can be combined with heaps, balanced BSTs, or segment trees for advanced problems (skyline, rectangle unions). Merge Intervals is simpler but limited to producing merged intervals.
Code Comparison
Merge Intervals
intervals.sort(key=lambda x: x[0])
merged = [intervals[0]]
for start, end in intervals[1:]:
if start <= merged[-1][1]:
# Overlapping — extend
merged[-1][1] = max(
merged[-1][1], end
)
else:
# No overlap — new interval
merged.append([start, end])Line Sweep (max overlaps)
events = []
for start, end in intervals:
events.append((start, +1))
events.append((end, -1))
events.sort()
active = 0
max_overlap = 0
for _, delta in events:
active += delta
max_overlap = max(
max_overlap, active
)How to Decide
- Does the problem ask to "merge overlapping intervals"? Use Merge Intervals.
- Does it ask for "minimum meeting rooms", "max concurrent", or "maximum overlap"? Use Line Sweep.
- Do you need the resulting list of non-overlapping intervals? Merge Intervals.
- Do you need a count or aggregate value derived from overlaps? Line Sweep.
- Is the problem 2D (skyline, rectangle union)? Line Sweep with an auxiliary data structure.
- Are you inserting a new interval into an existing sorted list? Merge Intervals approach (insert then merge).
Example Problems
Merge Intervals
- 1.Merge Intervals — Given a list of intervals, merge all overlapping intervals and return the result.
- 2.Insert Interval — Insert a new interval into a sorted list and merge any resulting overlaps.
- 3.Interval List Intersections — Find the intersection of two sorted lists of intervals.
Line Sweep
- 1.Meeting Rooms II — Find the minimum number of conference rooms needed (maximum concurrent meetings).
- 2.The Skyline Problem — Given building rectangles, find the skyline contour using sweep line with a max-heap.
- 3.My Calendar — Check if a new event can be booked without causing a triple-booking.